Costs: Explained

In the realm of law, the term ‘costs’ carries a unique significance. It refers to the expenses incurred by a party in the course of legal proceedings. These costs can be vast and varied, ranging from attorney fees to court filing fees, and from expert witness fees to the cost of obtaining and reproducing documents. Understanding these costs is crucial for anyone involved in a legal process, as they can significantly impact the overall financial outcome of a case.

Costs can be a complex topic, as they are influenced by a myriad of factors, including the nature of the case, the jurisdiction in which it is being heard, and the specific practices of the legal professionals involved. This article aims to dissect this complex subject, providing a comprehensive and detailed understanding of costs in the legal context.

Types of Legal Costs

Legal costs can be broadly classified into two categories: ‘Party and Party’ costs and ‘Solicitor and Client’ costs. Party and Party costs are those that are necessary and reasonable for the conduct of a lawsuit. They are typically awarded by the court to the successful party, to be paid by the unsuccessful party. On the other hand, Solicitor and Client costs are those incurred by a party in paying their own lawyer. These costs are generally higher than Party and Party costs, as they include all expenses incurred by a lawyer in representing their client.

It’s important to note that the actual costs incurred by a party in a lawsuit can be much higher than the costs awarded by the court. This is because the court typically awards only a portion of the actual costs, based on a schedule of costs prescribed by law. The remaining costs must be borne by the party itself.

Party and Party Costs

Party and Party costs, also known as ‘between party’ costs, are those costs that are necessary and reasonable for the conduct of a lawsuit. These costs include court filing fees, the cost of serving documents, the cost of obtaining and reproducing documents, and the cost of expert witnesses. They also include a portion of the lawyer’s fees, based on a schedule of costs prescribed by law.

The court typically awards Party and Party costs to the successful party, to be paid by the unsuccessful party. However, the court has discretion in awarding these costs, and may consider factors such as the conduct of the parties, the complexity of the case, and the reasonableness of the costs claimed.

Solicitor and Client Costs

Solicitor and Client costs, also known as ‘own client’ costs, are those costs incurred by a party in paying their own lawyer. These costs include all expenses incurred by a lawyer in representing their client, including time spent on research, drafting documents, negotiating with the other party, and appearing in court. They also include the cost of any disbursements made by the lawyer on behalf of the client, such as court filing fees and expert witness fees.

Unlike Party and Party costs, Solicitor and Client costs are not typically awarded by the court. Instead, they are agreed upon between the lawyer and the client, and must be paid by the client regardless of the outcome of the case. However, in some cases, the court may award Solicitor and Client costs to a party, particularly if the other party has acted in a vexatious or abusive manner.

Assessment of Costs

The assessment of costs is a process by which the court determines the amount of costs to be awarded to a party. This process involves a detailed examination of the costs claimed by the party, to ensure that they are necessary and reasonable. The court may reduce or disallow any costs that it considers excessive or unnecessary.

The assessment of costs is typically conducted by a court officer known as a ‘costs assessor’ or ‘master’. The costs assessor will review the costs claimed by the party, and may require the party to provide evidence to support their claims. The costs assessor will then prepare a report, recommending the amount of costs to be awarded. This report is subject to review by the court, which makes the final decision on the award of costs.

Factors Considered in the Assessment of Costs

In assessing costs, the court will consider a range of factors. These include the complexity of the case, the time and effort required to conduct the case, the amount of money involved, the importance of the matter to the parties, the conduct of the parties, and the reasonableness of the costs claimed. The court will also consider the schedule of costs prescribed by law, which sets out the maximum amount that can be claimed for various items of costs.

It’s important to note that the court has discretion in assessing costs, and may reduce or disallow any costs that it considers excessive or unnecessary. For example, the court may reduce the costs claimed for a lawyer’s time, if it considers that the lawyer spent an excessive amount of time on a particular task. Similarly, the court may disallow the costs claimed for an expert witness, if it considers that the witness was not necessary for the conduct of the case.

Procedure for the Assessment of Costs

The procedure for the assessment of costs begins with the party claiming costs (the ‘claimant’) preparing a ‘bill of costs’. This is a detailed statement of the costs claimed by the claimant, including a description of each item of costs, the amount claimed for each item, and the basis for the claim. The bill of costs is served on the other party (the ‘respondent’), who has the opportunity to object to any items of costs.

If the respondent objects to any items of costs, the claimant and the respondent will be required to attend a ‘costs hearing’, where they will present their arguments to the costs assessor. The costs assessor will then make a decision on the disputed items, and prepare a report recommending the amount of costs to be awarded. This report is subject to review by the court, which makes the final decision on the award of costs.

Recovery of Costs

The recovery of costs is the process by which a party who has been awarded costs by the court collects those costs from the other party. This process can be complex and time-consuming, particularly if the other party is unwilling or unable to pay the costs. In such cases, the party may need to take enforcement action to recover the costs.

The recovery of costs is typically conducted in accordance with the rules of the court in which the case was heard. These rules set out the procedure for the recovery of costs, including the steps that the party must take to enforce a costs order, and the remedies available to the party if the other party fails to pay the costs.

Enforcement of Costs Orders

If a party has been awarded costs by the court, and the other party fails to pay those costs, the party may take enforcement action to recover the costs. This may involve filing a ‘writ of execution’ with the court, which authorizes the seizure and sale of the other party’s property to satisfy the costs order. Alternatively, the party may apply to the court for a ‘garnishee order’, which directs a third party who owes money to the other party (such as an employer or a bank) to pay that money to the party instead.

It’s important to note that enforcement action can be costly and time-consuming, and there is no guarantee that it will be successful. For example, if the other party has no assets or income, or if the assets or income are located overseas, it may be difficult or impossible to recover the costs. Therefore, before taking enforcement action, a party should carefully consider the likely costs and benefits of the action.

Costs in Insolvency Proceedings

In insolvency proceedings, the recovery of costs can be particularly complex. This is because the insolvent party may have limited assets or income, and these assets or income may be subject to claims by other creditors. In such cases, the party who has been awarded costs may need to prove their claim in the insolvency proceedings, and may receive only a proportion of the costs awarded.

The rules for the recovery of costs in insolvency proceedings are set out in the insolvency legislation and the rules of the court. These rules provide for the ranking of claims in the insolvency proceedings, with certain claims (such as secured claims and employee claims) given priority over other claims. Costs awarded by the court are typically ranked as unsecured claims, which means that they are paid after the priority claims have been paid in full.

Costs in Different Jurisdictions

The rules and practices relating to costs can vary significantly between different jurisdictions. This is due to differences in the legal systems, the court rules, and the legal cultures of the jurisdictions. Therefore, when involved in a legal process in a foreign jurisdiction, it’s important to understand the local rules and practices relating to costs.

For example, in some jurisdictions (such as the United States), each party is typically responsible for their own costs, regardless of the outcome of the case. This is known as the ‘American rule’. In contrast, in other jurisdictions (such as the United Kingdom), the unsuccessful party is typically required to pay the successful party’s costs. This is known as the ‘English rule’. There are also jurisdictions (such as Canada) that follow a hybrid approach, with the court having discretion to award costs based on factors such as the conduct of the parties and the complexity of the case.

Costs in the United States

In the United States, the general rule is that each party is responsible for their own costs, regardless of the outcome of the case. This is known as the ‘American rule’. However, there are exceptions to this rule. For example, if a party has acted in bad faith or has brought a frivolous lawsuit, the court may require that party to pay the other party’s costs. In addition, certain statutes provide for the award of costs to the successful party, particularly in cases involving civil rights, consumer protection, and environmental protection.

The costs that can be recovered in the United States typically include court filing fees, the cost of serving documents, and the cost of obtaining and reproducing documents. However, they do not typically include attorney fees, except in cases where a statute provides for the award of attorney fees. The amount of costs awarded is determined by the court, based on a schedule of costs prescribed by law.

Costs in the United Kingdom

In the United Kingdom, the general rule is that the unsuccessful party is required to pay the successful party’s costs. This is known as the ‘English rule’. The costs that can be recovered include court filing fees, the cost of serving documents, the cost of obtaining and reproducing documents, and a portion of the lawyer’s fees. The amount of costs awarded is determined by the court, based on a detailed assessment of the costs claimed by the party.

It’s important to note that the actual costs incurred by a party in a lawsuit in the United Kingdom can be much higher than the costs awarded by the court. This is because the court typically awards only a portion of the actual costs, based on a schedule of costs prescribed by law. The remaining costs must be borne by the party itself. Therefore, even if a party is successful in a lawsuit, they may still be out of pocket in terms of costs.

Conclusion

Understanding costs in the legal context is crucial for anyone involved in a legal process. Costs can significantly impact the overall financial outcome of a case, and can be a major factor in deciding whether to commence or continue a lawsuit. By understanding the types of costs, the assessment of costs, the recovery of costs, and the rules relating to costs in different jurisdictions, parties can make informed decisions about their legal proceedings.

It’s important to note that this article provides a general overview of costs, and the rules and practices relating to costs can vary significantly between different jurisdictions and different types of cases. Therefore, if you are involved in a legal process, it’s advisable to seek advice from a lawyer or a costs consultant, who can provide detailed and tailored advice based on your specific circumstances.

Start Your Journey with Clear Legal

At Clear Legal, we understand that navigating legal costs can be complex and overwhelming. Our commitment to ethics, innovation, and quality ensures that we provide exceptional value and guidance to our clients and partners. If you’re facing legal proceedings and need clarity on the potential costs involved, we invite you to request a free consultation. Let us help you make informed decisions with the support of a team that aligns with your values and champions access to justice through technology.